110 Comments
User's avatar
includeMeOut's avatar

Such unhinged responses by the apologists for genocide under the rubric of fighting terrorism show that you are over the target, Doc. Keep it up.

Freedom Lover's avatar

An intelligent and decent Muslim begs to differ with expressed here ignorant Jew-hating opinions:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bhsUPagsgYU

William Tuesday's avatar

The Arabs have chosen to oppress the wrong group of people

User's avatar
Comment deleted
May 27, 2025
Comment deleted
Freedom Lover's avatar

Yea .. Israel chose to be pariah state, just like before: Kuwait did in 1991, Lebanon in 1986, Syria in the last 10 years, and Jordan in 1970 ...

Curious why you don't mention all non-Jewish states in your Jew-hating diatribe? ;) )))

Freedom Lover's avatar

Yea, if only I had a quarter for every Jew-hater’s “I love Jews, I have Jewish friends ….”

Do you hate Syria? How many thousands of Palestinian Arabs have been murdered in Syria?

Do you hate Kuwait? In 1991 Kuwait kicked out every single one of its 440,000 Palestinian Arabs. I wonder why?

Do you hate Lebanon? In 1986 Lebanon massacred tens of thousands and kicked out hundreds of thousands of Palestinian Arabs. I wonder why?

Do you hate Jordan? In 1970 Jordan massacred tens of thousands and kicked out hundreds of thousands of Palestinian Arabs. I wonder why?

Only stupid leftists, movement which in a short historic period murdered more innocents than all other movements and regimes in history combined, worry about Jews protecting themselves

Britton Leo Kerin's avatar

lol fucking moron the great thing about this is you sound EXACTLY like the "jews have been kicked out of 109 countries idiots" nice work moron

Freedom Lover's avatar

Palestinian Arab history from Rawaf al-Saeen taught to the Jew-hater, self-proclaimed moron Britton Leo Kerin

https://rumble.com/v3sj189-what-saudi-author-and-media-personality-rawaf-al-saeen-thinks-of-palestinia.html

Freedom Lover's avatar

Why would a nice smart person like you sign as "moron"? )))

“I always cheer up immensely if an attack is particularly wounding because I think, well, if they attack one personally, it means they have not a single political argument left.” Margaret Thatcher

You have not had a single argument to begin with, self-proclaimed moron )))

I am glad you are not disputing FACTS.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7avOS4YteuE

User's avatar
Comment deleted
May 27, 2025Edited
Comment deleted
William Tuesday's avatar

Its not 1939 anymore. Jews fight back now. Racist arab aggression will not go unanswered.

Sean's avatar

Jews fought back then as well. This is the equivalent of Nazis blockading the Warsaw ghetto and carpet bombing it daily (with more bombs than were dropped on all of Nazi Germany in WWII combined) for 20 months. Welcome to Nazi Israel, founded by antisemitic European terrorists who wanted to get the Jewish people out of Europe. So much for following Abrahamic law.

Freedom Lover's avatar

Of course you deny beig a Jew-hater. Being one destroys all your narrative. Yet, you bring Nazi Germany ... hmmmm I wonder why ... Pol Pot regime does not fit your picture? ;)

Funny, how skillfully you maneuvered to avoid addressing issues of Kuwait, Lebanon, and Jordan doing the same thing as Israel ...

Here is another test for an intelligent being:

1. Name Middle Eastern countries not called Israel which does not consider its Palestinian Arab population as the second class.

2. Name Muslim countries which doffers its Palestinian Arab population as many rights and as high standard of being as Israel offers its Palestinian Arab Population

.....

n. How many more Palestinian Arabs serve in Israeli Parliament and on the Supreme Court than in ALL Muslim countries combined

I am holding a full size mirror to you, so you don't miss the Jew-hater you are.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bhsUPagsgYU

hierochloe's avatar

A jewish man wrote that the Israeli flag was "a symbol that’s become the 21st century swastika". It's over, little hasbara chatbot. People know.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
May 27, 2025
Comment deleted
User's avatar
Comment deleted
May 27, 2025Edited
Comment deleted
Freedom Lover's avatar

"Oh, will prescription drugs stop our government from sending my tax dollars to murder children?"

Funny, you don't mind your tax dollars being stolen from the same children you claim to defend and enriching terrorist leaders, who, while not working a day of their lives outside politics, amassed incredible fortunes:

Naniyah $5 bln

Marzouk $3bln

...

Mashaal $5bln

The list is long. Stealing foreign aid sent to Palestinian Arabs is a marvelous money laundering operation.

You don't mind this use of your tax dollars, Jew-hater Kate SS?

Freedom Lover's avatar

"... every "Jew" I know agrees that it is Israel conducting the genocide ..."

1. Define genocide, so we can have an intelligent conversation, not terrorist propaganda debunking

2. You speak in logical fallacies. For example, your quote above is a fallacy called sample bias. Certainly you don't know many Jews. Hell, you don't know Muslim either. Here is one:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bhsUPagsgYU

Freedom Lover's avatar

I am confused. Define genocide.

Sean's avatar

According to the UN Genocide Convention (from the 1948 Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide)

Definition

Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide

Article II

In the present Convention, genocide means any of the following acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such:

Killing members of the group;

Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group;

Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part;

Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group;

Forcibly transferring children of the group to another group.

Jenny Nabben's avatar

Take me off your list. Hamas should return the hostages and stop using Palestinians as shields.

Jim's avatar

https://www.caitlinjohnst.one/p/its-a-complete-lie-to-say-gaza-can

Jenny: read this. Open your eyes. You think the destruction of almost all the buildings in Gaza, the destruction of all the hospitals, schools, medical facilities, not to mention the more-than-two months long blockade by Israel of all food, water, and medicine, the regular bombing of the tents sheltering all those whose homes have been bombed or blown to bits, hasn't produced a death toll as described in Matt Bivens' post? What planet do you live on?

User's avatar
Comment deleted
May 26, 2025
Comment deleted
Freedom Lover's avatar

Jew-haters do what Jew-haters do 🤷‍♂️

None of them mind real atrocities in Syria, Yemen, …, Rwanda. No Jews, no problem, no news. 😢🤷‍♂️

Jim's avatar

Why do you never mention that October 7th was a response to Israel's 17-year siege of Gaza, not to mention the hundred year war on Palestine? Are you so narcissistic that you are incapable of recognizing that a people locked in a cage, periodically bombed and shot, is eventually going to respond? You sound just like the fucking Nazis, in their response to the impudent Jewish partisans of the Warsaw Ghetto. What YOU are doing is guaranteed to increase hatred of Jews, because you claim that genocide, starvation, ethnic cleansing are Jewish values.

Freedom Lover's avatar

Funny Jim, is this your response to my comment about real atrocities in Syria, Yemen, …, Rwanda?

How many Palestinian Arabs have been murdered in Syria? No Jews no news?

You found a “justification” to the October 7 atrocity? What a monster you are!!

Why do you stop at 17 and 100? What about 3,000 war on Jews?

But I will answer your obtuse “17 years” question. In the year 2006 stupid Israel without any conditions moved all Jews out of Gaza, every single one, including dead. They left behind flourishing industry, like $100 million worth of greenhouses to grow fruits and veggies.

What was the first thing HamaSSTerrorist did? Correct, low up everything that would provide for independence of Palestinian Arabs from terrorists.

Then, they began to terrorise Israel and faced FAFO. What would AMY country do if its neighbour acted like Hamas terrorists? Exactly!! That’s what Israel is doing.

On a separate note, do tell, how many more Palestinian Arabs serve in Israeli Parliament and on the Supreme Court than Jews allowed to be alive in the territories controlled by Palestinian Arabs?

Jim's avatar

It was a response to Topogeejo's comment above yours. But to answer your attempts to deflect from the live-streamed genocide: THIS one is committed by MY country (the US), with massive funding and arms supplied to a crazed State that claims to exist in MY name (as a Jew.) Oh, and Israel was gung-ho for the head-chopper war on Syria, funded to the tune of billions of dollars by the US, which has now installed an Al-Qaeda maniac in power. Israel has seized even more of Syria through the mayhem. It's easy to point and disclaim the actions of "official enemies" or in countries to which we have no connection. The rubber hits the road when it's your own country committing the atrocities. You don't want to touch that, because from the tenor of your comment, you support what Israel is doing.

Your history, as with most Zionists, is made-up nonsense. Go read Ilan Pappe (Israeli historian) "The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine", to see how this criminal state (helmed by actual terrorists in the literal meaning of the word) was brought into existence. What we're seeing now is the culmination of 1947-48, which has always been the goal of Zionist settlers: drive out the people who were there long before the Zionists arrived (mostly from Europe), with the open threat (and implemented policy) to kill those who refuse to leave.

As with most all Zionists, every accusation you make is a confession.

Trying flipping around your broken telescope: what would any people do when subjected to the endless atrocities committed by Israel? Why are you surprised that an October 7th finally happened? Let me put this plain: YOU would be with the Nazis suppressing the resistance put up by the Jewish fighters of the Warsaw Ghetto. Your hasbara, and your actions, are no different.

Freedom Lover's avatar

👏👏👏

You can do it yourself, Jenny. In the top right corner, click on the three horizontal lines, then Subscriptions. Then choose Matt Bivens, sorry MD and do whatever you want. If you subscribed with payment, calling your credit card to cancel works the best

User's avatar
Comment deleted
May 27, 2025
Comment deleted
Freedom Lover's avatar

Please do!! Knock yourself out. ))) As a Liberal I am for the free choice. Just be careful, supporting terrorists is against the US law. Did not your Jewish friends tell you this? )))

THE END OF THE WORLD SHOW's avatar

Compares to the Warsaw Ghetto for size. Blaming it on Hamas is a real laugh. There is no Hamas on the West Bank and the same thing is happening there.

Freedom Lover's avatar

“ The Gaza Health Ministry published a list this week of 16,506 children killed by the Israeli military since October 2023.”

Does it pay this well to carry water for the terrorists, Doc? Since when intelligent docs are parroting terrorist propaganda? You really have to be ashamed of yourself!

Have you verified the data? Does it account for 78% of names, which even Hamas quietly removed from the list?

https://www.euronews.com/2025/04/03/hamas-run-health-ministry-quietly-removes-thousands-from-gaza-death-toll-researchers-find

I expect more reductions based on Jenin experience.

In 2002 Jenin Terrorist propaganda screamed and MSM dutifully parroted about 10,000 civilians murdered FOR MONTHS. Eventually, Hamas lowers the number to 5,000 … then 3,000 …

When finally UN finished its report, the total number of killed was 56, -Wikipedia now reports 52 -, with ONLY 9 civilians!!!

10,000 vs 9

That’s 1111 times fewer!!!

Dr. STOP doing terrorist bidding!! Either do verifying or STFU!!!

m droy's avatar

Keep bombing the hospitals then they'll have no one to report.

I really did not expect to find this much lunacy on Matt Bivens substack comments.

Who sent you?

Freedom Lover's avatar

Funny person, glad you are not arguing against the FACTS of TERRORIST propaganda LIES.

Your humor is overshadowed only by your ignorance, which in America is a bliss.

You know that by the laws of combat, hospitals, schools and all other civilian installation lose their protected status the moment the armed party enters them, don’t you?

So instead of speaking up against terrorists using civilians as human shields, you are attacking those who fight terrorists with UNPRECEDENTED caution.

I am sure you know all this. It’s blinding Jew-hate is what driving you.

Thank you for confirming my nagging suspicion what our joke of MD is about ;(

m droy's avatar

what a twisted person you have become.

When did it begin? 1948?

Freedom Lover's avatar

“ what a twisted person you have become.”

We know each other? oh, well, J guess, it takes one to know, right? 😉😘

Add another 3,000 years. Heard about Abraham? Jesus? No? I thought so.

m droy's avatar

Maybe you were always twisted.

Still having to lie to defend mass murder is a pretty sad place to be.

Terrorists - btw - you can't be a terrorist fighting against an occupier, just a abuse of words. But you know that, you know full well what you are.

Freedom Lover's avatar

Ah, but of course 😁 Occupier of your own country, which existed for 3,000+ years?

“ But you know that, you know full well what you are,” the Jew-hater 🤡😘

How many truly innocent Palestinian Arabs have been murdered in cold blood by Muslims in Syria? And you make not a pip about the real atrocity. Why is that? 🤡😘

All, every single one, of the 440,000 Palestinian Arabs were kicked out of Kuwait in 1991. Have I heard your kind making a single pip about that? 🤡😘

What about the Second Nakhba? Remember? 1970, no?

Tens of thousands murdered and hundreds of thousands expelled from Jordan. Your kind did not mind, did you? 🤡😘

It’s only when Jews fight to protect their kids, you have a problem.

Every word you write is evidence of your real self: Jew-hater!! 🤡😘

hierochloe's avatar

bruh... it's live streamed in 4k, much greater resolution than war crimes and human rights atrocities everyone could routinely watch since at least 2018 - but we're supposed to hand wring over the numbers and buy some bullshit from Henry Jackson Society and you can't even cite wikipedia accurately

you're just another Goebbels

William Tuesday's avatar

My concern is for the Israeli children only. Why in the world would anyone care about the enemy?

Freedom Lover's avatar

Well, if one is human, one must protect the innocent irrespective who they are, on which side. Children of Palestinian Arabs are no different. They MUST be protected and NOT used either as human shields or as props for sorry joke for the MD’s LIES.

Here is an interesting example of terrorists stripping Palestinian children of their innocence. AND THE WORLD HAS BEEN SAYING NOTHING!!!🤬🤬🤬🤬

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=vCWMBvxWKL0

If our sorry joke of MD had a semblance of decency, this is what he would be talking about, yet …

User's avatar
Comment deleted
May 27, 2025
Comment deleted
Freedom Lover's avatar

Yes, Jew-hater Kate SS, in DEMOCRATIC state Israel there are corrupt leftist publications which, unlike in Gaza, can express any opinion even incorrect ones.

Do name an individual in Gaza who expressed an anti-HamaSS sentiment and survived more than 24 hours.

Philip Lee's avatar

I've heard that Hamas stores weapons and builds command centers under hospitals and elementary schools. I've heard that they strap explosives and remote detonators onto young children and send them into crowded buildings and enemy military bases. I've heard that the GOAL of October 7th was to goad Israel into a retaliation that would kill as many 'Palestinians" as possible, thereby creating a public relations victory for the terrorists. It seems that their strategy has been wildly successful.

Freedom Lover's avatar

Something true rings in what you heard

An intelligent and decent Muslim begs to differ with expressed here ignorant Jew-hating opinions:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bhsUPagsgYU

Theo's avatar

This is unhinged and an uneducated rant. How are you an MD? If they want to stop the mass killing (which Hamas doesn’t; and we have no idea if the figures are true - Gaza health ministry???) RELEASE THE HOSTAGES. It’s fairly simple.

Freedom Lover's avatar

Why would Hamas be interested in stopping this? There leaders, while not working a day of their lives outside politics, amassed incredible fortunes:

Naniyah $5 bln

Marzouk $3bln

...

Mashaal $5bln

The list is long. Stealing foreign aid sent to Palestinian Arabs is a marvelous money laundering operation.

m droy's avatar

I saw this list translated to English, printed out and laid alongside the grass to one side of the Cenotaph, a war memorial, in Whitehall London.

During a demonstration on behalf of Gaza on Friday.

Quite moving. Very long.

Panjandrum's avatar

An organization called Genospectra Institute issued a document where it says -

"Over 702,000 Palestinians have died (or are dying)—140,400 from direct violence and over 561,000 from famine, deprivation, and medical collapse—according to conservative estimates grounded in The Lancet’s 4:1 excess mortality and capture recapture models."

To me this is corroborated by the use of israel's recent rhetoric to push 1.8 Million people of Gaza elsewhere as against the often used (and readers will recall) 2.4 Million population back in late 2023.

Source: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1OzfC_lKPvit4afqLtrzrzRU9uJmBl5XV/view

Freedom Lover's avatar

Oh my, this Jew-hater is lover of logical fallacies? :)) Herd of Confirmation Bias? ))

Any nonsense corroborate Jew-hating view. It's been proven that War Accepted Lancet 4:1 is WRONG in Israel's war for its existence. Actually less than 1`:1!!

An intelligent and decent Muslim begs to differ with your ignorant Jew-hating opinion:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bhsUPagsgYU

Erl Happ's avatar

Adam Smith in his book “An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations” (1776) wrote:

Most government is by the rich for the rich. Government comprises a large part of the organized injustice in any society, ancient or modern. Civil government, insofar as it is instituted for the security of property, is in reality instituted for the defence of the rich against the poor, and for the defence of those who have property against those who have none.

We should take an interest in what our government and their military, and the suppliers of the military, are doing.

The Hungarian PM Victor Orban recently said: If you see something bad in the world — especially something very bad — and you receive some instrument for its correction, then it is a Christian duty to take action, without undue contemplation or reflection.

Freedom Lover's avatar

Adam Smith was a very smart man:

Palestinian terrorist leaders, who, while not working a day of their lives outside politics, amassed incredible fortunes:

Naniyah $5 bln

Marzouk $3bln

...

Mashaal $5bln

The list is long. Stealing foreign aid sent to Palestinian Arabs is a marvelous, enriching, money laundering operation.

Freedom Lover's avatar

Could you drop a link to this Orban's quote please. It does not sound like something Orban would say.

An intelligent and decent Muslim's view:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bhsUPagsgYU

hierochloe's avatar

"Many of us like to ask ourselves, 'What would I do if I was alive during slavery? Or the Jim Crow South? Or apartheid? What would I do if my country was committing genocide?' The answer is, you're doing it. Right now.” RIP AB

You're doing the right thing. Fuck these hasbara chatbots and brainwashed swine. The truth is a tsunami travelling back and forth around the world now and ringing it like a bell - you didn't miss it for what it is - we need to ring it as loudly as we can.

#FIFP

Freedom Lover's avatar

What would you do if you were not a terrorist lover, Jew-hater?

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Dn0VZIy8jH0

Freedom Lover's avatar

An intelligent and decent Muslim begs to differ with your ignorant Jew-hating opinion:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bhsUPagsgYU

hierochloe's avatar

shared by an immoral gobshite that wouldn't recognize "Jew-hating" if it shat on their face

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eYVNhFfbdug

Freedom Lover's avatar

Well, well, well ... How's your Arabic, terrorist loving, Jew-hating troll? ;) )))

Palestinian Arab history from Rawaf al-Saeen:

https://rumble.com/v3sj189-what-saudi-author-and-media-personality-rawaf-al-saeen-thinks-of-palestinia.html

m droy's avatar

Matt - you must really have upset some nasty shits to be getting these posts on your substack.

I don't know who is bringing them here to attack this substack.

Well Done!

bhs66's avatar

“How can this be happening”?? When your a murderous terrorist death cult that abuses the citizens you rule and you openly call for the complete annihilation of Israel AND you brutally and viscously attack them AND take hostages maybe Hamas should have thought twice about attacking a country with superior war making abilities in all categories. Then when your getting absolutely destroyed you could have at any point stopped and given back the hostages! Hamas could have prevented every single thing that had happened in Gaza! Instead they persist and I for one under these circumstances hope every last one of them is killed, every last leader is killed, their tunnels(funded by the UN!) are destroyed. Only then will it stop. Hamas is like a wounded blood thirsty predator, Israel better finish it off otherwise the predator will come after them again.

Patrick Powers's avatar

Big Money wants those kids dead. In the USA Big Money gets what it wants. End of story.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WQgu0MpnKq8

Sean's avatar

The one statistic you could have added is the number of children killed in other US funded conflicts, whether killed by the US military, or killed by US backed terror groups. Otherwise, great, if extremely disturbing, reporting. Thank you for adding more visibility, and I hope you do not depend on Bari Weiss at The Free Press for funding.

Tess Wright's avatar

Tragic, & now these children are starving.

Freedom Lover's avatar

right ... if only Hamas has not been stealing the food sent by the world ...